Posted by Jimmy on August 03, 19103 at 08:50:48:

In Reply to: Re: Shelters of Stone posted by K. Bolstridge on August 21, 19102 at 04:26:24:

: : This book was hugely disappointing compared to the last 4! It was drawn out with way too much repitition right down to "washing the way Iza taught her so many years ago". Do you know how many times that is written in this book? The descriptions of the territory lasted pages on end. Ayla could do nothing wrong and was welcomed way too easily yet she was a foreigner with animals, raised by the Clan. Of all of the Zelandonii people, (and don't forget the Mamutoi summer meeting didn't have as many people as lived at the Ninth Cave alone) Ayla single handedly discovered all of these fascinating ways of doing things? It doesn't take 750 pages to prepare someone for the 6th book. A book of this many pages deserves to have a plot of its own especially after the number of years it took to get written.

Follow Ups:

• Re: Shelters of Stone Janey 09:28:02 8/03/103 (0)

Post a Followup